Return Home          More Investment Letters              
Investment Updates                                                           December 2004
 

Executive Summary

·         We expect relatively strong real GDP growth of +4.0% in 2005, the 4th consecutive year of economic expansion.

·         An accommodative monetary policy will transition to one of neutrality in 2005, as the Federal Reserve increases short-term interest rates from 2.25% currently to 4.0-4.5%.

·         Inflation should decline from +4.0% in 2004 to +2.5-3.0% this year. 

·         The value of the U.S. dollar should stabilize and even strengthen later in the year due to slower monetary growth and higher U.S. interest rates.  We expect the trade deficit to shrink in 2005 based on strong export growth. 

·         Although rising interest rates could eventually act as a restraint on equity valuations, this should be more than offset by strong economic growth, record earnings, and reasonable P/E ratios.

·          The 10-year U.S. Treasury Bond yield should increase to 5.0-5.5% from 4.22% currently.  A rising interest rate environment will make 2005 a difficult year for bond investments, especially longer-term issues.

Economy

Critics of the economy have once again been confounded by the above-average +4.0% growth rate of real GDP over the 12-month period ending in September 2004.  This strong level of economic activity appears to be sustainable as expectations are for +4% annual growth in the fourth quarter of 2004 and throughout 2005.  If our fourth quarter 2004 GDP forecast is correct, the economy will have grown at an annual rate of +4.2% over the past two years, well above the +3.1% average of the past 30 years.

Strong real GDP growth of +4.0% is expected for 2005 as a result of the stimulative effects of extremely low interest rates over the last 3 years (monetary policy), 3 years of government budget deficits (fiscal policy), 3 years of dollar weakness (currency policy), a revitalized corporate sector due to record corporate profits, an improving employment environment, and continued consumer spending as personal income is up +4.9% from a year ago with consumer net worth at record levels. 

We expect 2005 to be the year that the trade deficit begins to   shrink and business confidence, capital spending, and hiring return.  After three years of dollar weakness, businesses are finally starting to benefit from increased export growth and incrementally weaker import competition.  In addition, after falling in 2000 and 2001, corporate profits, as measured by the S&P 500, have increased by +18%, +19%, and +22% (est.) in 2002, 2003, and 2004, respectively.  The rise in profits gives corporations the confidence and the capital to begin spending for expansion, not just maintaining their businesses.  Corporate managements are starting to believe in the economy and are increasingly investing for future growth.  Evidence of this can be seen by the +10% growth in durable goods orders in 2004, an all-time high in small business optimism, and the return of employment growth.  The increased spending and hiring bodes well for a longer, more sustainable period of economic growth. 

CHART 1:  Corporate Profits At Record Levels and Still Growing!

Federal Reserve

Federal Reserve monetary policy has been highly stimulative to economic growth for the last three years and continues to induce expansion (see Chart 2) despite the recent hikes in short-term interest rates from 1.0% in June 2004 to 2.25% at present.  Easy monetary policy results in faster economic growth, higher inflation, and a weaker dollar.   

CHART 2:  The Fed Funds Rate Still Highly Stimulative!

 

 

With strong growth, rising inflationary pressures, and a weak dollar, we expect the Fed to continue raising interest rates until the real Fed Funds rate (nominal rate less inflation) is at a neutral range of 1.5%-2.0%, which indicates a nominal Fed Funds rate of 4.0-4.5% by the end of 2005.  As the Fed increases short-term interest rates and slows monetary growth, the value of the dollar should stabilize and even strengthen later in the year. 

Because of the deflation scare in 2002, the Fed has stated that it will err on the side of growth, which leads us to believe the Fed will pause when the real Fed Funds rate reaches 1.5-2.0%.  The key factor will be the inflation trend.  If the current increase in inflation proves to be mostly transitory in nature due to the rise in oil prices and the inflationary effects of the decline in the dollar, the Fed may be able to stop raising rates sooner than we anticipate.  Since monetary policy works with a 12-18 month lag, it should continue to have a positive effect on economic growth through 2005 and even into 2006. 

 

Inflation

The rate of inflation has been increasing over the last two years from +1.6% in 2002 to +2.3% in 2003 and an estimated +4.0% in 2004.  Most of the increase has been due to the rise in oil as the core CPI (excludes food and energy) has been fairly stable since 2002.  Core inflation was +2.3% in 2002, fell to +1.5% in 2003 and increased to an estimated +2.6% in 2004.  Despite the increase, core inflation is still well contained (see Chart 3).

 

CHART 3:  Core CPI Rising But Still Well Contained

 

Within the core CPI, the goods deflation experienced in 2002 and 2003 has ended with some inflation in 2004, while the services inflation has actually declined from +4.0% to +3.0%.  With oil prices falling, we expect the overall rate of inflation and the core CPI to converge at +2.5-3.0% for 2005.

Fiscal Policy

President Bush is pursuing a strong pro-growth agenda in his second term, which includes Social Security reform, tort reform, budget restraint, a new energy policy, and tax reform.  Instead of promising additional giveaways, the President is trying to remove a number of restraints on our economy and encourage ownership and capitalism.  If he is able to push through much of this agenda, it will be positive for the economy and our competitive position in the world.  The last pro-growth agenda of this magnitude dates back to the Reagan Administration.  What followed was one of the longest U.S. economic expansions and one of the strongest bull markets in history. 

Stock Market

The large capitalization S&P 500 Index finished with a +9.2% return for the quarter while total returns from smaller capitalization stocks (Russell 2000) and foreign equities (EAFE) were even higher at +14.1% and +15.3%, respectively.  For the year, the S&P 500 increased by +10.9%, the Russell 2000 by +18.3%, and the EAFE by +20.2%.  Strong corporate profit growth, the end of the Presidential election uncertainties, the increased likelihood of the dividend and capital gains tax cuts being made permanent, and the relatively robust economic growth fueled the rally.  The weak U.S. dollar contributed to the above-average foreign equity performance. 

Despite the rebound in stock prices, we still find the case for owning stocks to be strong.  Corporate earnings are continuing to grow, P/E ratios are reasonable at 16.2 times 2005 S&P 500 EPS estimate of $74, and longer-term interest rates will still be relatively low even after a 100-125 basis point increase.  Although concerned about investor reaction to rising interest rates, we believe that a healthy economy, increasing corporate profits, and reasonable valuations will be more than enough to generate solid equity returns in 2005.

Bond Market

The yield on the 10-year U.S. Treasury Bond increased to 4.22% from 4.12% in the fourth quarter.  Our fixed income benchmark, the Salomon Broad Investment Grade Bond Index, produced a total return of +1.0% in the quarter and +4.5% for the year.  We continue to recommend a shorter-than-average duration for bond portfolios in anticipation of a rise in the 10-year U.S. Treasury Bond yield to +5.0%-5.5% over the next year, resulting from strong economic growth and higher core inflation.  The current 10-year U.S. Treasury Bond yield is just marginally higher than the rate of inflation.  Bond investors have typically required a +2-3% real return over the rate of inflation, which is why we remain relatively cautious on bonds.

Management Meetings

During the second half of 2004, in addition to having teleconferences with various corporate executives, members of our investment team have traveled to Illinois, Maryland, Michigan, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, and Virginia to meet with managements from Midwest Bank Holdings, Career Education, American International Group, Cendant, Henry Schein, North Fork Bancorp, Pfizer, Thor Industries, Illinois Tool Works, Hospira, Compudyne, Fiserv, Citizens Banking, Comerica, Oxford Bank, Hershey Foods, Dearborn Bancorp, Virginia Financial, Center Financial, Columbia Sportswear, Radisys, and La Crosse Footwear.

 

In accordance with SEC Rule 204-3(b), our Form ADV Part II is available upon request.  Please call or write to Susan C. Beaver, North Star Asset Management, Inc., P.O. Box 8012, Menasha, WI  54952-8012.